Emily and her father have been having more arguments than usual.
Two weeks ago, they had a real doozy. I ended up - as usual - mid combatants - trying to get both of them to listen to each other. For Terrance belongs to the "I can raise my voice louder than yours, therefore you must bow to my magnificence" school of parenting. I belong to the "If I can out think you, or out last you, or simply ignore you long enough, I will win" school.
You can see where the two may collide.
Emily has both the great good fortune, and the great misfortune to have a combined repertoire of both schools of thought. She can be a virtual chameleon, switching between styles. Unfortunately, she tends to use Terrance's own style ON him. This means two people, trying to out-shout one another. Each attempting to assert some dominance, gain the upper hand on one another.
It started as a normal walk to school. Then, Terrance began to say goodbye. He leaned down to kiss her. She ran to the playground. He called her name. She ignored him and kept running. He follows her onto the playground. She attempts to dodge. He catches up to her.
He says "Why did you keep running? I called to you. You do not run away when I call your name!"
She, from both accounts, remains standoffish. He uses the standard black father threat: " Don't make me beat your ass in front of all of your friends - because I will!"
He tells me of her bolting when he walks back home. He is angry.
Later that evening, I broach the subject with her. Why on earth did she run from him as he called her?
The story tumbles out. It was the Kiss. She bolted because he kissed her. Near the Playground. She was embarrassed, sure her friends would laugh at her. And when he followed her onto the playground, her mortification was complete.
Being a Mom, being a teacher, being a researcher of young children, this makes sense to me. Emily - then a few weeks away from being nine - is more than dipping her toe in the waters of puberty. She is dipping in half a leg, and then running and screaming because her leg is wet. The world is a jumbled mess. She is attempting to now define herself as separate from her family, but MORE separate from her father.
With the release of the hormones which are clearly changing her body, the changes in her consciousness of what it is to be female are at times more painful to bear. For all of us.
So while I understand and empathize with her, Terrance does not. After she and I discuss the situation, I invite her father to the conversation. He is offended. He is affronted. He is combative. He refuses to agree to not kiss her in front of the playground. He rages at her that he doesn't care if every one of her friends thinks she is a baby, or if everyone of them laughs at her. He is her father and he loves her and he will kiss her.
She rejects his logic. She informs him that she does not want him to kiss her. She yells at him, he bellows back. They storm.
Then, he seems to give a little. He offers to only kiss her on the top of the head, and not on the cheek in front of her friends.
As I am weighing the implications of this laurel branch, Emily rejects it outright. There will be no kissing. She is not a baby and she will not be kissed.
And so the storm continues.